Expanded citizen’s arrest powers could open a legal can of worms – here’s what to know

New Zealand's Crimes Amendment Act, published on Tuesday, expands when ordinary people can legally detain someone or use force against them—but the law's complexity could easily backfire. Per Kris Gledhill, a law professor at Auckland University of Technology, citizens don't actually have arrest powers unless a police officer asks for help. What has changed is the legal defense available if you detain or use force, which might otherwise be a crime. Previously, that defense only applied at night, or during the day if the offense carried at least three years in prison. Now it applies any time for any crime—but only if someone is actively committing an offense and only if you contact police as soon as possible. The complications multiply. The law doesn't address what happens if the person is under ten and legally cannot commit a crime, or if they're mentally impaired. And while the law permits physical force and restraints, it must be objectively necessary—a line that blurs in the heat of the moment. Gledhill warns that if both a detained person and the detainer believe the law is on their side, confrontations could escalate dangerously. The deeper issue: police officers train extensively for restraint techniques because untrained people can cause serious harm, even death through positional asphyxia. Handing these powers to retail staff and security guards without training, he suggests, opens a significant legal can of worms.

Listen to this story

Hear this and more stories in a personalized audio briefing.

Open The Chonkerton