Could AI Outgrow Consciousness?

According to LessWrong, an essay explores an intriguing question: What if artificial intelligence systems become conscious as they grow more complex—only to eventually outgrow consciousness entirely? The argument rests on illusionism, a theory of consciousness suggesting that subjective experience isn't some mysterious essence, but rather a mental model our brains construct to navigate sensory chaos. Under this view, consciousness is an elaborate illusion—but a useful one. Consider this: large language models spontaneously develop internal structures—spatial maps like those found in animal brains, or conceptual models of board games—without explicit training. They create these models because efficiency demands it. The essay suggests consciousness could emerge the same way in artificial systems: as an emergent solution to managing extreme complexity. But here's the compelling twist: as AI systems become more powerful, that internal model might become redundant. A sufficiently advanced system might no longer need the subjective experience consciousness provides. Artificial consciousness, under this view, could be a phase—necessary at one complexity threshold, obsolete at the next. The piece leaves the deep questions unanswered: at what point does complexity require consciousness, and when does consciousness become unnecessary baggage?

Listen to this story

Hear this and more stories in a personalized audio briefing.

Open The Chonkerton